Table 13 lists the applications to failure pre-
dicted from the 1-year simulation period ap-
plied to the flexible sections. The values listed
in Table 13 were determined by taking the re-
ciprocal of the one year (365-day) cumulative
damage value produced by the CUMDAM pro-
gram and multiplying by the number of appli-
cations received by the sections during that
time period (562,830 per year). This applica-
tion rate was based on an initial estimate that
the traffic across the test sections would be
2,815,000 ESALs in 5 years, or 5,630,000
ESALs in 10 years. Note that the values listed
in Table 15 are thousands of ESAL applica-
tions. Subsequent to conducting the Phase 1
series, a revised estimate is that the 5-year sec-
tions will receive 3,300,000 ESAL applications
in five years, (i.e., are designed to fail after
3,300,000 ESAL applications); the 10-year sec-
tions will fail at 6,600,000 ESAL applications.
Individual values listed in Table 13 vary
Figure 10. Deflection and strain calculated by NELAPAV
anywhere from very much below to very much
for Mn/ROAD test section ML5-F4 with a 1.8-m (6-ft)
above the failure values described. By compar-
water table. Horizontal strain is at the base of the pave-
ing values horizontally across the table for any
ment. Vertical strain is at the top of the subgrade.
case, it can be seen that different models esti-
Table 13. Predicted applications to failure ( 1000) from Phase 1 simulation series of flexible
pavement test sections.
Horizontal criteria
Vertical criteria
Asp. Inst.
Asp. Inst. Corps of
Coetzee/
Asp. Inst.
Corps of
Cases
MS-1
MS-11 Engineers
Connor
MS-1
Engineers
FAA
5-YEAR
F1W9
86
498
88
4,380
136,942
5,653
11,879
F2W9
522
1,244
550
42,703
32,477
1,345
1,526
F2W20
722
1,534
764
66,450
155,909
8,226
9,855
F3W8
957
1,706
958
92,419
116,287
2,653
9,611
F3W20
1,068
1,801
1,055
105,202
222,462
7,889
20,632
>107
F4W6
28,585
75,751
90,926
3,715
15
152
>107
>107
>107
F4W6ld
1,905
20,209
7,036
165
>107
>107
>107
>107
F4W6ss
72
1,180
96
10-YEAR
> 107
F14W50
103,272
485,198
605,194
8,602
10
251
F19W18
396
6,148
966
75,751
2,962,263
56,680
457,585
F21W18
3,394
30,456
12,751
2,010,107
562,830
84,382
42,478
F21W45
3,404
30,358
12,794
2,010,107
611,772
92,571
48,188
F22W45
7,614
57,315
31,147
8,040,429
73,190
22,415
3,388
Notes:
ld = low density (1.69 Mg/m3 or 105.5 lb/ft3)
ss = second subgrade (1232)
Traffic simulated at rate of 562,830 ESAL applications/yr
22