600
400
200
Outagamie County Airport
R2 = 0.8
0
400
200
600
Subgrade Modulus from WESDEF (MPa)
Figure 20. Relationship between subgrade moduli backcalculated by
WESDEF and ILLIBACK.
40 x 103
30
20
Outagamie County Airport
10
Loc 7
Loc 9
Loc 23
0
13
14 Mar
19
24
29
3 Apr
8
18
23
28
Figure 21. Typical backcalculated PCC modulus from ILLIBACK (OCA).
calculate the partial basin areas and found that none sig-
oped. Basin area results from ILLIBACK and WESDEF
nificantly increased the correlation with the calculated
are shown for both OCA and CWA in Figures 22 and
subgrade modulus.
23. In Figure 22, the total basin area was calculated us-
A similar relationship between ISM and subgrade
ing all seven deflections. In Figure 23, the basin area
modulus is shown in Figure 24. A second-order polyno-
was calculated using the third to seventh deflections.
mial function provides the best fit to the data. Again, a
Previously, we had determined that the thaw depth
better correlation is obtained using the results from IL-
under AC pavements could be related to the partial ba-
LIBACK.
sin area calculated using the third to seventh deflec-
The results from OCA and CWA are combined in
tions (Janoo and Berg 1990). The current data indicate
Figures 25 and 26. In Figure 25a presents a relationship
that this partial basin area (A3-7) may be related to the
developed between the measured total basin area and
subgrade modulus. The figures show that as the total
subgrade modulus calculated from ILLIBACK for both
basin area or partial basin area increased, the subgrade
sites. An excellent correlation between total basin area
modulus decreased. A power relationship was found to
and subgrade modulus is found. In Figure 25b, the rela-
best fit the total basin area or partial basin area and the
tionship developed between the total basin area and
subgrade modulus. We also found that a better correla-
subgrade modulus calculated from WESDEF for both
tion existed with the subgrade modulus obtained from
sites is presented. There are two distinct trends. This is
ILLIBACK. The use of the partial basin area (A3-7)
probably attributable to the separation of the base and
(Fig. 23) did not significantly increase the correlation
subgrade in WESDEF. Again, a power curve seems to
20